The Truth About “Fishy” Caviar (And Why Ours Never Is)

Timur Altman
Updated
The Truth About “Fishy” Caviar (And Why Ours Never Is)

One of the most common concerns people have when trying Black Caviar for the first time is: “Will it taste fishy?”

If caviar is truly premium and properly handled, the answer is no. High-quality Black Caviar is buttery, smooth, and delicately briny—never overwhelming or unpleasant.

So why do some caviars have an overpowering fishy taste? The answer lies in freshness, sourcing, and craftsmanship.

What Causes Caviar to Taste Fishy?

A strong fishy taste is a sign that the caviar is either low quality, improperly stored, or past its peak freshness. Here’s what can cause this:

  • Poor Sourcing & Processing – Inferior caviar is often harvested from stressed fish or processed under improper conditions. This affects the final taste.
  • Oxidation & Exposure to Air – Caviar that isn’t properly sealed and stored can develop an off-putting flavor as it loses its delicate balance.
  • High Salt Content – Over-salted caviar (often used to extend shelf life) can amplify unwanted flavors instead of enhancing natural richness.
  • Improper Storage – Caviar must be kept at -2°C to 2°C at all times. Temperature fluctuations can degrade its quality.

Key Takeaway

If caviar tastes overly fishy, it’s likely due to poor sourcing, oxidation, excessive salt, or improper storage—not the nature of caviar itself.

Pro Tip: Always buy from trusted sources that focus on freshness and ethical sourcing.

What High-Quality Black Caviar Should Taste Like

The best caviar has a flavor profile that is rich, creamy, and elegantly briny—never overpowering. Each variety has its own distinct characteristics:

  • Beluga Caviar: Smooth, buttery, and delicately oceanic with a long, elegant finish.
  • Osetra Caviar: Nutty, complex, and slightly briny, offering a refined depth of flavor.
  • Kaluga Hybrid Caviar: Bold, buttery, and slightly fruity, with a clean, lingering taste.

Key Takeaway

Premium caviar should be balanced, refined, and complex—not overwhelmingly fishy or salty.

Pro Tip: Roll the caviar pearls on the roof of your mouth instead of chewing to experience its full depth of flavor.

How to Tell If Your Caviar is Truly Fresh

Even high-quality caviar can lose its signature taste and texture if not stored and handled correctly. Here’s how to ensure it’s at its best:

  • Check the Smell: Fresh caviar has a mild, oceanic scent—never overly fishy or pungent.
  • Look at the Pearls: They should be firm, glistening, and intact, not mushy or broken.
  • Taste the Balance: Premium caviar is lightly salted using the Malossol method to enhance, not overpower, its natural flavor.
  • Store it Properly: Keep caviar at -2°C to 2°C, sealed in its tin, and consume within 48 hours after opening.

Key Takeaway

Fresh, high-quality caviar is mild, refined, and perfectly balanced—never overpowering or unpleasant.

Pro Tip: If caviar smells or tastes too strong, it may have been improperly stored or past its prime.

Final Thoughts: Why Premium Black Caviar is Never Fishy

A fishy taste is never a characteristic of true luxury caviar. The best Black Caviar is defined by freshness, balance, and purity—with no harsh aftertaste.

Key Takeaways

  • High-quality caviar is never fishy—if it is, something went wrong.
  • Poor storage, excess salt, or improper sourcing can cause unwanted flavors.
  • Fresh, properly stored caviar has a creamy, buttery, and delicately briny taste.

Timur Altman

Timur Altman is the co-founder of Royal Touch Caviar, a brand dedicated to curating the...
Learn More
Recipes
Know Your Caviar—The Difference Between Black and Red Caviar
There’s nothing like a caviar celebration — and it doesn’t need to cost you an arm and an egg
Does Caviar truly have to be stored and served cold?
Featured
How to serve the Caviar to impress your guests?
Classification of caviar by type of preparation
How can you spark up traditional serving of black caviar?
explore our caviar

Two Tantalizing Options